Midcentury study blamed comic books for society’s ills

Midcentury study blamed comic books for society’s ills

Photo by Erik Mclean on Unsplash

August 2025

Everything Old

Midcentury study blamed comic books for society’s ills

by Corbin Crable

In this issue of Discover Vintage America, we examine the history and popularity of comic books, that highly entertaining form of ephemera that also has become highly collectible.

As we prepare to bid farewell to summer, our minds might travel back in time to those carefree afternoons when we felt the warmth of sunshine on our faces as we lounged outside with a glass of lemonade in one hand and a comic book in the other.

The appeal of comics seems as if it only continues to grow even as the medium has undergone major changes in recent decades. According to data supplied by Grand View Research, in 2024, the global market size for comic books stood at $9.38 billion. By 2030, that number is expected to swell to $17.52 billion.

“Comic books and graphic novels appeal to both children and adults, offering a unique storytelling experience that blends visuals with narrative,” the report notes. “Many readers prefer them over traditional novels as the combination of text and imagery enhances engagement and emotional connection. Graphic novels also serve as a form of escapism, allowing readers to immerse themselves in imaginative worlds beyond reality.”

In recent years, the explosion of North American children and adults consuming Japanese comic books called manga has breathed new life into the medium. Even those critics of manga might shrug and say, “Well, at least my child is reading,” while a secondary benefit has been a boost to Japan’s tourism industry as manga fans pour in from other countries with perhaps a romanticized version of the country and its culture in their minds. And vintage comic book heroes are returning to the pages of comics, this time in digital form – companies and websites like gocomics.com allow fans to read the latest issues with a subscription. It’s given me the chance to meet my favorite characters like Dick Tracy and Flash Gordon all over again.

Like all other forms of media, this popularity didn’t always exist. Quite the opposite, in fact. In the 1950s, at the height of the Red Scare, German-American psychiatrist Dr. Frederic Wertham expressed a deep concern about the effects of violence in mass media. His most notable published book on the subject was titled “Seduction of the Innocent.” The book, published in 1954, made the argument that comic books were to blame for juvenile delinquency due to its excessive portrayal of violence; Wertham also claimed that hidden sexual themes could be found in comics. To bolster his claims, Wertham included comic panels he found especially offensive.

Wertham argued his case to Congress as well; that congressional hearing was broadcast on the even newer medium of television. The massive platform granted to Wertham on Capitol Hill was enough to put several comic book publishers out of business.

In subsequent years, Wertham’s study has been criticized for many reasons. The teens who made up his small sample population was nearly exclusively made up of boys from troubled homes and who had pre-existing behavioral disorders. The study’s claims were supported by anecdotes, not objective, scientific data. And today, those who review the text find that Wertham failed to adhere to most of our modern basic research standards.

Though Wertham’s book is still read by psychiatrists for a good laugh, it was an altogether failed study. These days, video games have been identified as the new scapegoat, with critics recycling Wertham’s same arguments.

Now, in this issue, we’re giving comics their due as a medium that still entertains, excites, and sparks our collective imagination. And hey, who knows? There even might be some money to be made from those old Archie comics in your attic.

 

Contact Corbin Crable at editor@discovervintage.com​

Porchfests put a song on the lips  of passersby

Porchfests put a song on the lips of passersby

July 2025

Everything Old

Porchfests put a song on the lips
of passersby

by Corbin Crable

When I was a young boy, my parents would always drive by an old farmhouse on the way out of town. Without fail, no matter the time of day, on the porch would be sitting an elderly couple, waving at the cars driving by. It was a comforting, heartwarming sight, seeing two people making others’ day brighter by offering a simple greeting from their porch. You could always count on them being there.
Several years ago, though, the porch sat empty. I assumed the kindly couple had passed on. A short time later, the house was demolished, and with it, a cherished time when people took life at a slower pace and paused to appreciate the smaller gestures of goodwill that people like them provided.

These days, porches remain spaces where one can relax and watch life unfold; now, however, the gesture of greeting comes in the form of small gatherings called “porchfests.” A porchfest is a small music festival, with each musical artist or group playing on the front porch of homes.

They can be found in communities both large and small, and they’re a somewhat recent phenomenon, having begun in Ithaca, NY, in 2007. More than simply a music festival, they were begun in order to gather local musicians and local residents of a particular city and create a sense of community.

If you live in one of the neighborhoods in which a porchfest takes place, you may volunteer your porch as a “stage” of sorts for a musician or group. Signs are posted in front of your porch with the name of the artist and the time(s) at which they will perform. Feel free to bring a lawn chair and soak up a variety of musical genres – you’ll find nearly every one, from jazz and blues to rock and R&B.

Here in our coverage area, you can find at least one porchfest in just about every state in which you can find this publication. In Kansas, Atchison hosts such an event at the start of each summer; Missouri has Kansas City and Joplin, while Omaha, NE, hosts its own porchfest as well.

And in Iowa, head to Indianola and North Liberty to listen to some tunes that will get your toes tapping.

It’s important to remember what a porch symbolizes in order to fully appreciate such an event. The porch should be seen as a hub for social interaction – a place where you can get to know your neighbors and feel more connected to the community in which you live.

“The porch symbolizes community, neighborhood and conversation,” writes Campbell McCool in his article “Celebrating the American Front Porch” on www.strongtowns.org. “When you ask people about their favorite front porch, many recall a kinder, gentler time.”

We’ll continue our own celebration of the front porch in this issue of Discover Vintage America with our cover story on the history of porch swings. And don’t forget to reconnect yourself with your own front porch this summer, be it on a warm summer day or a cooler summer evening. Take a seat, pour yourself a glass of lemonade, enjoy the splendor of that colorful sunset, maybe listen to some music of your own (or just the sound of cicadas in the distance), and cherish those slower, beautiful moments with neighbors and friends.

Contact Corbin Crable at editor@discovervintage.com​

Kitchen items worth their weight  in memories, moolah

Kitchen items worth their weight in memories, moolah

Photo by Daria Rudyk on Unsplash

June 2025

Everything Old

Kitchen items worth their weight in memories, moolah

by Corbin Crable

Roll up your sleeves and don your aprons, because this month’s issue of Discover Vintage America is headed into the kitchen as we explore antique and vintage kitchen appliances. But let’s not forget about those smaller kitchen tools that we might take for granted but hold just as many memories (and usefulness) in the pursuit of culinary perfection. It’s always good, too, to know their potential monetary worth. Is there money to be found in your everyday vintage kitchen items? Is Grandma’s old mixing bowl worth anything?

An article published last month on delish.com attempts to answer these and other questions. As you might expect, that cast iron skillet, which you have to remind your husband not to wash every time it’s used, is one of the most valuable of kitchen tools. Those pieces from the 19th and early 20th centuries are the most difficult to find, with skillets made by companies like Griswold and Wagner fetching especially high prices online – anywhere from a few hundred dollars to a few thousand.

CorningWare! What 20th century kitchen didn’t have these pieces as among the most often used. Made from Pyroceram material (itself invented in 1958), Corning-Ware, with its cornflower blue floral design, has earned a reputation of being durable. These can be worth up to a couple of hundred dollars.

Next to licking the mixing spoon, using cookie cutters are easily the best part about baking a fresh batch of sugar cookies (my favorite!). The three things you want to look for when starting a collection of cookie cutters are color, size, and shape – those pieces that are either extra large or extra small are highly sought-after, and “darker tins distinguish hold old the items are,” according to delish.com. You can buy old cookie cutters for as little as $25 or as much as a couple of hundred dollars as well.

Every home needs a KitchenAid Mixer, those sturdy old workhorses from midcentury America. KitchenAid’s inaugural model, the Model H-5 mixer, was released more than a century ago, in 1919. The most coveted models from the 1930s and ‘50s usually fetch high prices as long as they’re in great condition, but much of their value is sentimental, evoking memories of mom or grandma.

Would you actually believe that the everyday mason jar has increased in value, due mostly to their recent resurgence in use? It’s true. The first Ball mason jars were released in the 1880s, and jars from brands such as Van Vliet can be worth up to $20,000 or so. The value of these jars depends on a variety of factors, from the brand to the color of the glass, from the lid type to the type of glass used, according to delish.com.

Remember when you’d get your hand caught in the cookie jar as a child? Nowadays, you might find the cookie jar itself an even bigger treat. Again, like the KitchenAid mixer, the cookie jar enjoyed a heyday of more than 20 years, from the 1930s through the 1950s.

We’ll be preheating the oven as you scan the vast expanse of the Internet, hunting for the value of your vintage kitchen tools. And we’ll call you when dinner’s ready!

 

Contact Corbin Crable at editor@discovervintage.com​

Jukebox songs that put a song  in our hearts

Jukebox songs that put a song in our hearts

Photo by The Retro Store on Unsplash  &  jukebox (Image courtesy of rock-ola.com)

May 2025

Everything Old

Jukebox songs that put a song in our hearts

by Corbin Crable

In this issue of Discover Vintage America, we place the jukebox under a figurative magnifying glass, exploring its history and its mass appeal. The warm glow of its multicolored lights and the boom of the speakers transport us to simpler times – maybe a first date or a stop at a cozy little dive bar.

There are songs that just seem to sound better when played on a jukebox as well. It’s an unexplainable phenomenon, but if you’ve ever used a jukebox and been overcome by a wave of nostalgia, you know exactly what I mean. Many lists of the best jukebox tunes exist; we’re going to check out one list from Spotify. How many of these songs have you heard on the ol’ jukebox?

 

  •  “Girls Just Wanna Have Fun” (1983) by Cyndi Lauper: Originally written from a man’s perspective, we can be glad that Cyndi Lauper got her hands on the song, rewriting the lyrics for a different audience. Considered a feminist anthem, the song’s lyrics stand as a celebration of friendship among women.
  • Love Shack” (1989), The B-52s: The song’s famous shack, complete with a tin roof (rusted), was inspired by a small club in Athens, GA, which B-52s frontman Fred Schneider said “looked like a shack … You opened the door and there was a wild band playing.” Becoming an instant classic, it’s no wonder that the song is now a staple at all B-52 concerts.
  •  “Stayin’ Alive” (1977) by The Bee Gees: Immortalized in the film “Saturday Night Fever,” this disco anthem appears at number 189 on the list of The Rolling Stones’ 500 Greatest Songs of All Time.” Despite its catchy beat, the song is actually about survival on the streets of New York City.
  • American Pie” (1971) by Don McLean: McLean’s song is a tribute to the musical heroes of his childhood – early rock ‘n’ roll musicians Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens, and The Big Bopper, all of whom were killed in a Feb. 3, 1959, plane crash. A song of both nostalgia and disillusion, at 8 minutes and 42 seconds in length, you’d be certain to get your dime’s worth when you listen to this classic on the jukebox.
  •  “Hotel California” (1977) by The Eagles: You can check out anytime you like, but you can never leave! Widely regarded as one of the best rock songs ever produced, the meaning of its lyrics continues to mystify music fans. In the 2013 documentary History of The Eagles, the band’s Don Henley said the song “is about a journey from innocence to experience. … That’s all.”
  • Rock Around the Clock” (1954) by Bill Haley and His Comets: Some of your older family members likely danced to this ditty when it was released in the 1950s; Gen Xers like me will, meanwhile, will recognize it as the song from the opening credits on the TV show “Happy Days” (you know – that show where Fonzie had to give a certain jukebox a good punch to turn it on!).

These are just a few songs that jukeboxes across America continue to play time and again. And as long as we keep the coins coming, they’ll continue to be enjoyed for years to come. Let the music play!

Contact Corbin Crable at editor@discovervintage.com​

What were we thinking? Bizarre dishes of yesteryear

What were we thinking? Bizarre dishes of yesteryear

Image created by adobe firefly

April 2025

Everything Old

What were we thinking? Bizarre dishes of yesteryear

by Corbin Crable

The star of the show in this month’s issue of Discover Vintage America is the aspic – that oft-consumed dish that seemed to be synonymous with kitchens and dinner parties of midcentury America. But I’d like to introduce you to some of its lesser-known cousins, true culinary disasters that we all hope don’t make a comeback anytime soon. You can view the images accompanying each food here: www.msn.com/en-gb/foodanddrink/news/33-strange-and-spectacular-foods-from-the-20th-century/ss-BB1ndgx7#image=1

Chicken pudding:

Chicken baked in batter with herbs. Especially popular at the beginning of the 20th century, simply “imagine the textures of quiche and cake, and covered in gravy.”

Ambrosia:

OK, so sue me, but I actually have always enjoyed this one … well, at least in the iteration in which we find it today, as a fluffy, fruit salad/dessert.

But in the early 20th century, ambrosia was quite different in composition, appearance, and taste – “It was light and refreshing, simply orange slices and coconut layered in a dish with sugar.” It wasn’t until chefs in the South got a hold of the dish that ingredients like raisins, nuts, cherries, marshmallows, and Cool Whip were added.

Creamed chipped beef:

Again, most of us are already pretty familiar with this Depression-era dish, with chipped beef pressed and salted, then rehydrated in white sauce and poured over toast. My grandfather, like most of his generation, referred to this cost-effective meal as “shit on a shingle.”

Hoover stew:

Named for President Herbert Hoover, who occupied the White House during the Great Depression, this stew combined macaroni, canned tomatoes, and chopped hot dogs. It was a perfect option for families who had to stretch their dollar.

Spaghetti casserole:

Invented in the 1950s, the makeup of this dish was just about what you would expect – spaghetti, tomato sauce, whatever vegetables and meat you had on hand, and grated cheese. Who doesn’t love a good, hearty casserole, especially here in the Midwest?

Meat and potato

patties: Developed in the 1940s, this was another meal option that made meat go further in the days of food rationing. Obviously, think ground beef mixed with diced potato, and there you have it – a filling foodstuff that served as “a great alternative to 100% beef hamburgers.”

Need a drink to go with your meal? Try 7-Up (or your choice of a lemon-lime soda) and milk, a stomach-turning concoction marketed by (you guessed it) the fine folks at 7-Up!

You know what? Now that I mention it, most of these recipes don’t sound so bad! And, in this era of quickly-rising grocery prices, hopefully they’ll serve as an inspiration as you ponder how to stretch your food budget. Bon appetit to all!

Contact Corbin Crable at editor@discovervintage.com​