Hitting all the right notes: Novelty Music Boxes
September 2026
SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE
Hitting all the right notes: Novelty Music Boxes
by Donald-Brian Johnson
Snoopy. . .that fiddle-player from Fiddler on the Roof. . .Winnie the Pooh. . . the Easter Bunny. What could the members of this unlikely quartet possibly have in common?
Well, at one time or another, they’ve each been featured on a novelty music box. Joining them: a multitude of other pop culture characters, from Minnie Mouse to Humpty Dumpty. Also churning out the music box tunes: plenty of easily recognizable things (souped-up ‘50s roadsters, merry-go-rounds); easily recognizable places (Alpine hillsides, the “Little Brown Church in the Vale”); and easily recognizable generics (little kids with pets, old men puffing on pipes, sad-faced clowns. . .the list is never-ending).
Novelty music boxes are often gifts for special occasions (birthdays, graduations, weddings, anniversaries, etc.) Some celebrate certain times of the year (Christmas for sure, but Easter, Halloween, and St. Patrick’s Day are in the mix). Even holiday-themed music boxes usually stay out year-round, since many do double duty: open the lid, and there’s a velvety-cushioned repository just right for miniature mementos.
Numerous novelty music boxes are fashioned of china, metal, or glass. A bit higher up on the value ladder: all-wood, hand-carved boxes. A bit lower down: all-plastic. But regardless of their base material, the function remains the same. Wind them up (or, on the newer battery-operated versions, flip a switch), and the music boxes repeatedly tinkle out identifiable 18-note segments of a popular or semi-classical tune. You can even make a reasonably accurate stab at the manufacture date by identifying the song that’s playing (If it’s the “Theme From Love Story,” chances are good the box dates from the 1970s).
The music box heritage is a lengthy one. The very first “mechanical musical instrument” is credited to a trio of brothers in Baghdad, who created a “hydropowered organ” in the 9th century. By the 13th century, a bell ringer in Flanders had come up with a means of making his job easier, with pins and cams mechanically striking out melodies on the church bells. Over the next several centuries, a variety of mechanized musical objects continued to pour forth from inventive minds. There were towering musical clocks and tiny musical snuff boxes, plus plenty of musical automata, like the jeweled singing bird Hans Christian Andersen wrote about in “The Emperor’s Nightingale.”
He’s playing the title tune: “Fiddler on the Roof” ceramic music box. Price Import, Japan, 7” h. (Image courtesy of the author)
That lovable beagle Snoopy — and Woodstock, too! The ceramic windup plays “O Christmas Tree.” Schmid, 1980. 9” h. (Image courtesy of the author)
Early musical mechanicals were primarily toys for the well-to-do. More affordable music boxes had to wait until the early 1800s, when skilled Swiss watchmakers turned their talents to music-making. Essentially, what came to be recognized as a “music box” played its simple melody when a set of pins on a revolving cylinder plucked the teeth of a steel comb.
The music box industry received a major boost in 1870 with the introduction of removable discs. While the function was the same, a cylinder could play just one melody. With removable discs, a change of disc, a turn of the crank, and a music box could play tunes aplenty. By the early 1900s, they had become a must-have household staple. As the Sears, Roebuck & Co. catalog put it:
“In any home, rich or poor, the music box will be a pleasure. No costly music lessons are necessary, as the music produced by this beautiful instrument is just as charming and delightful as that of any piano.”
During its heyday, plenty of music boxes were sold (Regina, the industry leader, is estimated to have moved at least 100,000). But, by the 1920s, the player piano and the phonograph had captured the ear of those in search of mechanized music. Today, antique cylinder and disc music boxes command the big bucks, as do their modern recreations.
Fortunately, vintage novelty music boxes, with their pop culture themes and 18-note instrumentals, remain perfectly in tune with today’s pocketbooks; most sell for well under $50. That’s one reason why they continue to attract gift-givers looking to please gift-getters (Well that, and who can resist Snoopy?).
Donald-Brian Johnson is the co-author of numerous Schiffer books on design and collectibles, including “Postwar Pop,” a collection of his columns. Please address inquiries to: donaldbrian@msn.com
Five of a kind: The Dionne Quintuplets
May 2024 SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Five of a kind: The Dionne Quintuplets by Donald-Brian Johnson In the 1930s, Shirley Temple was America’s sweetheart.Ah, but there was only one Shirley. There were five Dionnes. Ninety years ago, on May 28, 1934, the Dionne sisters,…
Planting time: Fascinating figural planters
April 2024 SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Planting time: Fascinating figural planters by Donald-Brian Johnson Spring is here at last! Time to break out the spades, and break in those new gardening gloves. Time to ferret out that trowel from wherever you stashed it last fall….
Hoppin’ down the bunny trail: America’s Easter traditions
March 2024 SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Hoppin’ down the bunny trail: America’s Easter traditions by Donald-Brian Johnson “Here Comes Peter Cottontail, Hoppin’ down the bunny trail, Hippity, hoppity, Easter’s on its way!” (Steve Nelson & Jack Rollins, 1950) That Gene…
Valentine boxes evoke childhood memories
February 2024 SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Valentine boxes evoke childhood memories by Donald-Brian Johnson Here’s a memory-jogger: it’s Valentine’s Day in mid-20th century America, and across the country, nearly every elementary school classroom has something in common….
This month: ‘Just an old Christmas card’
December 2023 SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE This month: ‘Just an old Christmas card’ by Donald-Brian Johnson Here’s when the Christmas season really gets underway: one wintry day, amongst the deluge of bills and ads, your daily mail coughs up something out of the ordinary….
This month: ‘Heads Up! Character Wall Masks by Bossons’
November 2023 SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE This month: ‘Heads Up! Character Wall Masks by Bossons’ by Donald-Brian Johnson Ever wanted to study a “Tyrolean” up close? How about a “Smuggler?” A “Fisherman?” A “Fiji Islander?” For collectors of Bossons Character Masks,…