Giving thanks for Betty Crocker
November 2025
SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE
Giving thanks for Betty Crocker
by Donald-Brian Johnson
Thanksgiving dinner at my house?
Why, sure. Say, could you bring the rolls? And the cranberries? And the vegetables and mashed potatoes? Oh, and the turkey and stuffing. And a pumpkin pie would be nice.
Hey, come back here!
Once again, “dinner at DBJ’s” is doomed. The thing is, I can’t cook. Not a lick. I would if I could, but I can’t.
Not that I haven’t tried…but food entering our kitchen always seems to suffer a mysterious fate. It spoils. It melts. Sometimes it even bursts into unexpected flames.
You’ve heard of folks who “can’t boil water?” That’s me. I tried it once and ended up scorching the saucepan.
That’s why I’m always a bit jealous of people who can cook, especially when holidays like Thanksgiving roll around. I drown my sorrows paging through vintage homemaking magazines, and there they are: folks just like me, bustling about, putting up their festive holiday décor, and effortlessly preparing meals of mouthwatering magnificence.
The décor items I can handle. The meals? Well…
Then one day at a rummage sale, I ran across two resources guaranteed to turn the (kitchen) tables in my favor: the 1959 book, “Entertaining With Betty,” and, from 1971, “Betty’s Recipe Card Library.”
The “Betty” in question? Why, Betty Crocker, of course! If Betty couldn’t transform me into Chef Boy-Are-DBJ, then nobody could!
So, I bought them.
In “Entertaining,” Betty gets things off to a cheery start: “Here is a book about hospitality, and how it can be easy and fun.” Sounds encouraging. First, Betty answers a few pesky pre-party-planning inquiries: Question: “Is it all right to invite guests of different political persuasions?” Answer: “It is never amiss to say ‘Joe is working hard on the election – and not for your candidate. But forgive him that, and you’ll enjoy him.’”
Soon though, she gets down to the real meat-and-potatoes of the thing: those recipes! These are divided into numerous helpful categories: “Buffet Dinners”; “House Parties”; “Come By For Dessert and Coffee,” and “Midnight Suppers” (not to be confused with “Stag Parties,” the category that follows it). The recipes seemed straightforward enough, so I decided to give one that Betty lists under “Emergency Meals” a try: “Flaming Chicken.” Ingredients included Bing cherries, Mandarin oranges, butter, and black pepper. Oh, and chicken. Betty’s final instruction: “Brush chicken with 2 tsp. lemon extract, and touch burning match to it.” I did. My “Flaming Chicken” went up in flames.

The complete “Betty Crocker Recipe Card Library.” 648 cards, in a sunshine yellow box. 1971, $40-50. (Image courtesy of the author)

She’s everywhere! “Entertaining With Betty” by Betty Crocker, 1959. A 2017 reissue of 1959 original, $15-20. (Image courtesy of the author)
On to the recipe cards!
Nestled in their very own sturdy hard plastic box (color choices ranged from “Sunshine Yellow” to “Avocado Green”), the 648 index cards are carefully organized by category. Some categories (“American Classics”; “Seasonal Favorites”) are timeless. Others revel in their 1971 underpinnings. “Men’s Favorites,” for instance: “When he yearns for food like mother used to make, bring on your ‘Chicken Fricassee with Dumplings,’ light as a cloud. If he insists the simple things in life are best, wait ‘til he tastes your ‘Savory Duckling On A Spit!’”
One side of each card provides the recipe, plus novel serving suggestions. (For “Tuna Chow Mein Casserole,” “surprise the family with homemade fortune cookies” Yes, that would be a surprise). The reverse of each card however, is the real treat. Ready for their closeups are glamour photos of glistening hams and scrumptious shortcakes, sure to prompt even the most inept cook (me) to start pre-heating that oven. So what if you never actually get around to preparing “Peanutty Pork Chops” or “Cherry Pineapple Bologna”? Just looking at the pictures is enough to whet any appetite. As Betty herself put it, “the right kinds of meals can bring a glow to complexions, sheen to hair, health, and good cheer to your whole family’s outlook.” So can thinking about them.
Now, which shall I try first? Hmmm. The “Cherries Jubilee” sure look tasty. And I think there’s flame involved.
Happy Thanksgiving!
Out of their shells: Collecting vintage egg cups
April 2025SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Out of their shells: Collecting vintage egg cupsby Donald-Brian Johnson Are you a pocillovist? Wait. Let’s rephrase that.Do you collect egg cups? If so, you’re into pocillovy (from the Latin, pocillum ovi, “a small cup for an egg”)....
Batteries not included – some toys keep going and going…
March 2025SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Batteries not included - some toys keep going and going...by Donald-Brian Johnson Toys are for kids, right? Well... except those intended for “kids at heart,” like the battery-operated figures which hopped off store shelves and into...
Collectible calendars: Chronicling the days of our lives
February 2025SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Collectible calendars: Chronicling the days of our livesby Donald-Brian Johnson It’s 2025! Out with the old, and in with the new! Clean those closets! Dump those dresser drawers! Jettison the junk and start the new year with a...
Away in a Manger: Nativity sets of the world
December 2024SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Away in a Manger: Nativity sets of the worldby Donald-Brian Johnson “And she brought forth her first-born son,and wrapped him in swaddling clothes,and laid him in a manger...” In Germany, it’s called a Weihnachtskrippe. Spaniards...
Child’s play: family-friendly ‘Play Mates’
November 2024SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE Child’s play: family-friendly ‘Play Mates’by Donald-Brian Johnson Hey there. . .check out this month’s Play Mate!Now that I have your attention. . . Once upon a time, “play-mate” meant something a lot different than it did to the...
The collecting spirit: Haunting Halloween collectibles
October 2024SMACK DAB IN THE MIDDLE The collecting spirit: Haunting Halloween collectiblesby Donald-Brian Johnson The scene: a suburban basement, circa 1960. Orange and black crepe paper streamers have been carefully taped to the rafters. Cardboard die-cut images of...

