Cast iron cookery – a timeless skill

October 2025

Good Eye

Cast iron cookery – a timeless skill

by Peggy Whiteneck

My dad swore by cast iron cookware. He liked using it to cook over his antique cast iron cooking stove (We had a gas range, but he preferred the old stove). He said the cast iron pans heated more evenly and made food taste better – and when I visited my parents as an adult and ate at their table, I had to agree!

Dad was very particular about his cast iron cookware – most of which was, like the stove, antique or near-antique. I remember with fond smiles the way Dad objected to Mom’s insistence on washing the pans with soap and water, which Dad said ruined the patina. My dad took to wiping out the pans with paper towels, oiling them, and then putting them away in the old stove’s oven as soon as possible after he’d used them and before mom could notice. Most of the time, he got away with it.

In addition to his frying pans, Dad also had other cast iron cookware, among which was a very large, handled pot which hung over the fireplace on the other side of the stone chimney into which the old cast iron stove was vented. He cooked in this pot only very rarely since the fireplace didn’t produce the more uniform heating in his cast iron stove, for which the pot was too large.

Manufacturers of Cast Iron Cookware

The most famous name in cast iron pots and pans was Griswold. This company, founded in Erie, PA, dates from 1865. Its pots, skillets, and bakeware are marked on the bottom with the name Griswold in a square cross enclosed in a double-rim circle. The company ceased production in 1957, but the pans can be found on the secondary market in antique shops and online auctions. They are very popular among cooks, and it’s not unusual to see them priced in three figures today.

In the 1910s, the name on the back of the pans was in a subtly italicized form within the cross and circles. In the 1920s and ‘30s, the Griswold mark appeared in block lettering; it is these pans that are most desirable on the secondary market today. This logo was large and extended over almost the entire bottom surface of the cookware. Beginning in the early 1940s until the company ceased production in 1957, the size of the name and its surrounding logo became much smaller.

Along with each of these Griswold logos was inscribed the place of origin, Erie or Erie, PA. The Griswold brand name was acquired in 1957 by the Wagner foundry, which continued making cast iron cookware through the mid 1960s with the Griswold logo but without the Erie, PA, since Wagner was located in Sidney, Ohio. In the early to mid-1960s, the pans were marked with both the Griswold and Wagner logos.

Lodge was another maker of cast iron cookware, founded in 1896 and still in production. Its first factory was destroyed by a fire – a frequent early 20th-century disaster at foundries and potteries that had open fires for production. The Blacklock family, which founded and owned the company, opened a new factory nearby as Lodge Cast Iron, which is still in operation today. The surfaces of its pans are somewhat rougher than Griswold’s, and it is priced much more economically on the secondary market than either of its rivals, Griswold or Le Creuset.

 

Coudersport Duck on Nest

Griswald cast iron pan

The italicized brand name dates this Griswold pan, in fantastic condition, to the factory’s earliest years in the 1910s. These pans were made in various sizes; this one is number 8. It sold on eBay for $250 on Aug. 31, 2025. The numbers on Griswold skillets ranged from 2 to 14 for household skillets; the enormous number 20 was meant for hotel use. (Image courtesy of the author)

Le Creuset was founded in 1925 and still operates today. It is popular for enameled cast iron in various colors. Its cooking-surface cast iron is smoother than Lodge’s. Its wares are expensive at retail, though not as expensive as some of the secondary market prices of Griswold, which remains the king of cast iron cookery among collectors. No matter what stove you cook on – wood, gas, or electric – what’s not to love about an antique you can still use for its original purpose?

Peggy Whiteneck is a writer, collector, and dealer living in East Randolph, VT. If you would like to suggest a subject that she can address in her column, email her at  allwritealready2000@gmail.com.

Laying down a Tile

September 2025

Good Eye

Laying down a Tile

by Peggy Whiteneck

Wall tiles aren’t just an antique decorative accent but a treat for modern collectors. They have a long history: Ancient tiles were being used for paving various surfaces as early as centuries before Christ. But most of the oldest wall tiles seen today date from the 1880s and have become collectible in their own right as well as sought after for home décor. Some older tiles were made of metal, but collector interest today is focused on the ceramic tiles. They were originally used as backing behind stove pipes, as flooring, or as decorative accents in hallways or around doors. These inlaid tiles were described using the adjective “encaustic.” As described on Giovanni’s Tile Design web site, giovannistile.com/blog/the-history-of-decorative-tiles, encaustic tile combines a plain clay base with a stamped area that is filled with colored liquid clay and fired to fuse the different layers together. These encaustic figural art motifs are the tiles of most interest to collectors today.

Antique ceramic tiles were usually about a half inch thick vs. a quarter inch for modern tiles. Still, the thicker width of old tiles did not protect them from damage; it is often difficult to find undamaged tiles today, especially sets of matching older tiles for contemporary home renovation projects. Damage could happen over time while the tiles were in place, or they could be damaged in the process of dismantling and removing them. Tiles taken directly from walls will often have on their backs the cement used to install them, which prevents identification of the maker’s mark and patent and pattern numbers that are usually included on the backs of the original tile. Collectors prefer clean backs that reveal these manufacturing details.

Manufacturers Worldwide and Close to Home

Decorative tiles were a worldwide manufacturing phenomenon. Most of the more famous tile manufacturers were based in the United States, England, Portugal, Morocco, and Japan. Over time, the term “Moroccan” has been used to denote a style rather than a point of origin. But the most famous and original Moroccan tile maker is Zellig, which was actually founded in Morocco and has been functioning for centuries right up until today.

Perhaps the most famous of American decorative tile companies was the J. & J.G. Low Co., founded in Chelsea, MA, in 1877; it closed in 1902. Other American companies founded in the late 1880s included the American Encaustic Tiling Co. in Zanesville, OH (which later morphed into the Shawnee Co.) and Grueby Faience Co. in Revere, MA (closed in 1921). The backs of American Encaustic tiles are marked simply with the company’s initials A.E. (An English company called Alfred Meakin from the 1920s is also marked simply with initials A.M. The use of just the initials may seem to us today a bit of braggadocio by companies so proud of their work they didn’t even have to use the whole name, but it’s more likely that early tile making was restricted to just a few companies, making the use of the initials more readily identifiable at the time).

 

Coudersport Duck on Nest

Alfred Meakin wall tile

This Alfred Meakin wall tile sold on eBay in July for $200. It is marked on the verso AM LTD ENGLAND. Meakin also made border tiles for outlining room surfaces that are sought-after collectibles today. Scarcity of a tile pattern will affect its value, and you can still find figural Meakin tiles for less than $50. Image courtesy of the author

In England, Minton’s China Works was founded in 1868 and closed in 1918, and Alfred Meakin, Ltd. was founded in 1875 and functioned under Alfred and, later, his son until the son’s death in 1908. The Meakin tiles had gorgeous floral and flowing forms in their Art Deco design. A Japanese company, Danto Kaisha, also working in the Art Deco style in this period, marked its tiles solely with its initials D.K. Another company in Japan working in the Art Deco style also identified its tiles by its initials, M.S.

Well after these older companies folded, a number of 20th-century manufacturers stepped in to create ceramic tiles still available for home projects today. Most examples of antique tiles remain affordable (many under $100 each) though a few of the rarer examples may cost several hundred dollars. Find your own tiles with style!

Peggy Whiteneck is a writer, collector, and dealer living in East Randolph, VT. If you would like to suggest a subject that she can address in her column, email her at  allwritealready2000@gmail.com.

Eggs not laid in Nature

August 2025

Good Eye

Eggs not laid in Nature

by Peggy Whiteneck

There’s just something really pleasing about an egg’s shape, whether it comes from hens – or glassmakers! Many companies made functional versions of white glass eggs, beginning in the late 19th century, to be placed as a prop in a nest to entice hens to lay real eggs. They worked quite well for that purpose!

Much later, Fenton made affordable eggs on stand as well as larger, free-standing, blown forms. Fenton eggs on stand were made occasionally as early as the mid 1970s but were issued annually from 1990 until the factory closed in 2011. These were solid and easy to mould. Versions were painted with every decoration Fenton artists could imagine.

The Fenton solid eggs on pedestal weren’t my favorites. I only have a couple of them, but my sister Rosie loved them, and I bought them for her whenever I found one. When she died a couple of years ago, her son, who’d already become an avid Fenton fan under our family’s influence, inherited her Fenton collection.

The larger blown Fenton eggs, on the other hand, were more fragile, both to produce and to collect. They were made as special editions for the Fenton Art Glass Collectors of America (FAGCA), one of two national Fenton glass clubs. I have two of these hand-decorated blown eggs, one in Topaz Opalescent Rib Optic and one in Blue Opalescent Rib Optic. The blue one is atypically unmarked as a FAGCA piece. I was able to confirm its authenticity only when I saw it in the club’s own glass collection, where it was also unmarked as a FAGCA.

Fenton also made a blown egg for QVC in a pattern called Roses on Diamond Optic Burmese (Fenton made this pattern for QVC in many shapes and forms). I acquired one of these eggs at a Fenton Museum de-acquisition auction in 2014 with the hand-painted Museum mark on its base, 69.99.37. In decoding those numbers, 69 meant it was made for QVC, 99 for the year (1999) it was acquired for the Museum, and 37 for the sequence of acquisition.

Artisan Eggs

Although Fenton is probably the best-known 20th century maker of decorative versions of glass eggs, they were also made by Murano and Annalise. Murano eggs on stand retail for $300-$400!

Dave Fetty made blown eggs for Fenton in “Mosaic,” colored swirl (“Crayon”) patterns, and “Hanging Hearts.” After 33 years there, Dave had “retired” from Fenton in 1998, but the company asked him to come back to produce special forms in his inimitable style. His work for Fenton is signed “DLF” above “Fenton” in a convex oval mark stamped into the glass itself, as found on the base of the eggs. Fetty survived a bout with COVID in 2020 with no long-term effects and is still making glass – in a career that started at Blenko Glass when he was just 19. Now in his 80s, he still freelances for Mosser and other glassmakers.

Fetty also worked with glass carvers Kelsey Murphy and Robert Bomkamp (the latter now sadly deceased) on various Fenton glass forms; Fetty would blow out the form and then Kelsey and Bomkamp, who worked with other companies in addition to Fenton, would carve it. I have in my collection a large, freestanding egg by Fetty/Kelsey/Bomkamp, featuring carved chicks on a blue overlay egg. This one was probably a one-of-a-kind as I have found no other records for it. I purchased it at a FAGCA consignment auction held during the club’s national convention in 2016. 

Coudersport Duck on Nest

Fenton Alley Cat

One of the blown eggs made for FAGCA, this one in a decorated Topaz Opalescent Spiral Optic form from 1997. These are not easy to find on the secondary market. Because they are hollow, it’s likely that not all of those produced have survived into the present. (Image courtesy of the author)

Blown eggs, generally unattributed to an artisan, can also be found in an online search. They tend to be very inexpensive (under $20) and were made as occasional knickknacks for home décor rather than as collector pieces.

And there you have it: a clutch of incredible, inedible eggs! Can’t cook ‘em for breakfast, but they sure do make a feast for your eyes!

 

 

Peggy Whiteneck is a writer, collector, and dealer living in East Randolph, VT. If you would like to suggest a subject that she can address in her column, email her at  allwritealready2000@gmail.com.

All dolled up – To play or not to play

June 2025

Good Eye

All dolled up – To play or not to play

by Peggy Whiteneck

Children’s toys have been sought by adult collectors, especially items in their original packaging. For me, keeping dolls and other toys in original cardboard and cellophane is kind of a turnoff, as it subverts the very function of the item it encloses – something to be held and played with. Historically, dolls have had many functions, from child’s play to religious use – emphasis on ‘use.’

The history of dolls

Dolls date from 2000 years before the birth of Christ! Some have thought early dolls, made of various materials such as wood, clay, ivory, rags, and even corn husks, were used exclusively for religious purposes. However, dolls have been found in children’s graves “dressed in the latest fashions,” which seems to indicate that dolls also had roles in teaching and, yes, as playthings. Early cultures that had dolls included Africa, Japan, Russia, Germany, and the Netherlands. The indigenous Hopi of North America had Kachina dolls, usually made of carved wood and decorated in various ceremonial dress, that were used as messengers of gods or ancestors or as ritual items (www.historyofdolls.com).

Much later, in the late 19th and early 20th centuries, dolls became styled as “baby dolls” or as young children so that the kids who played with them could be pretend parents. Many of these dolls were remarkably accurate in their rendition of an infant’s head and facial features. Old dolls may contain a manufacturer’s mark on the back or back of the neck. (By the way, boys can play with them, too! A nephew of mine played with dolls among his “boy toys” and grew up to be a loving father of children of his own.)

African-American versions of dolls came out in the 1930s and ‘40s, but they were definitely a minority production, even by the 1980s, when I was an administrator at a rehab hospital and nursing center in North Miami. I bought dolls and other toys with funds donated by benefactors and the facility itself to be given out free of charge to adult staff, many of whom struggled to afford Christmas for their kids. I made it a point to include as many dolls as I could find with black and brown “skin,” and was deeply and genuinely annoyed to find they were so hard to find! But I kept shopping for them. More than one mother who came to my “store” became teary-eyed as she chose a doll with dark skin; more than one told me it was the first doll that actually looked like her own child that she had ever found.

And then there was Barbie (and Ken!)

There has perhaps been no bigger fad among kids or adult collectors than Mattel’s Barbie and, later, her beau, Ken. Barbie was made in a huge variety of sometimes elaborate costumes, depending on the profession she was designed to represent. These dolls came with an endless variety of accessories, from personal care items and costume changes to cars and houses. The first basic Barbie dolls from the 1960s were produced in bathing suits, with additional costumes that could be bought separately. The early Barbies were sometimes accused of fostering unrealistic and harmful body image for girls, and minor changes in the body were introduced in later versions to respond to these concerns.
Barbie was originally envisioned as a white creation. But consumers soon began asking for black and brown Barbies, and Mattel company complied.

Dolls made for adult collectors

Late in the 20th century, elaborately coiffed and dressed dolls began to be produced as collector items for adult buyers. These were mostly mail-order items advertised in magazines and were so carefully made that they would not have lasted more than a day or two in the hands of a playing child, no matter how careful the child was. Consumer taste is slow to evolve, and the feminine-gender appeal of dolls has continued throughout their history.

Coudersport Duck on Nest

TThis late 19th century French doll made by Francois Gauthier (marked FG on back of neck) sold on eBay in May 2025 for $2,171.25. She was not the most expensive doll sold recently on eBay; several sold higher, including a Bru Jn-marked doll that sold in late April for $12,000! The highest-priced antique dolls seem to be in barely-played-with condition with very minor flaws.

 

 

Peggy Whiteneck is a writer, collector, and dealer living in East Randolph, VT. If you would like to suggest a subject that she can address in her column, email her at  allwritealready2000@gmail.com.